The Right to Know

Do we really have a fundamental right to privacy?  On Thurs., Sept. 19, 2013 faculty, students and neighbors gathered at Heritage Commons to celebrate Constitution Day and to explore the many rights being debated regarding the public's right to privacy, the fight against terrorism and the gay rights movement. 

Retired New Hampshire Supreme Court Justice Representative William Batchelder and the former President of the American Civil Liberties Union and Law Professor Nadine Strossen shocked and impressed the audience as they spoke openly about the recent Supreme Court decisions regarding civil liberties.

Plymouth's own Mark Fischler, Chairman of the Criminal Justice Department, directed the conversation toward the Constitution's role in these recent decisions. He addressed one of the most talked about issues, "Should the government eavesdrop on your phone and email conversations?" Batchelder expressed his state of shock over the amount of information that can be sent through technology and our right to privacy. 

Strossen explained that this is one of the bigger issues that has mushroomed since the 9/11 terrorist attacks. She stated, "We all have the right to privacy." Her biggest question was, "Is surveillance actually necessary?" A faculty member asked if the surveillance issue is something we can potentially fight. Strossen responded by expressing that the public should keep their voice heard to keep pressure on lawmakers.  

The discussion of Gay marriage stirred up many opinions and concerns including whether or not it will be legalized across a national level or if it will be left to the state legislators. Both speakers referenced the right to privacy court cases including the Roe v. Wade case and the United States v. Winser cases. Batchelder explained that this issue has been everywhere and back in regards to the court and the public eye, "It has moved the ball around the field."  

Cases upon cases are being brought forth to the supreme court in hopes to legalize gay marriages in all states. Strossen explained that Roe vs. Wade helped as a cautionary note to the Supreme Court. Batchelder kept the conversation in motion by asking what must occur for them to make that step. Strossen replied by stating, "it's only a matter of time," in regards to the legality of same-sex marriage across the country.

Mark Fischler concluded the conversation with a final question, "What advice do you have for the young students who are about to enter the real world and interact with the Constitution and their rights?" Both speakers smiled as if the answer was simple. Batchelder answered, "Your judgment is no better than your information. Nothing is more dangerous than a half-truth. Be perceptive." 

Strossen informatively followed by stating, "Know your rights, cherish them and stand up for them. Challenge anybody who tries to restrict them."